The Court called Congress' action a "bill of attainder"and gave Congress the hardest rap in more than a decade.
The majority opinion, written by Chief Justice Earl Warren, declared that the Landrum-Griffin provision was a bill of attainder, and therefore unconstitutional.
The champions of the last Plantagenet also cite a bill of attainder, or disqualification, brought by Henry VII against his predecessor after Richard died at Bosworth.
Did Congress just pass a bill of attainder punishing a dead man? Congress has passed legislation ordering national cemetery officials to disinter the remains of a killer. Could this be considered a bill of attainder, the kind banned by the Constitution? Click to Continue »
Dec. 11, 2013 - McClatchy Washington Bureau
Judd Gregg in Bloomberg It's basically targeted on a small group of people, which is technically a bill of attainder,Gregg said. "Even though it may be drafted to be broad, it's actually targeted."
Jerrold Nadler in NPR The court made the right decision in this case,Nadler wrote me in an e-mail. "I am gratified that my analysis of the punitive and blatantly unconstitutional bill of attainder has been vindicated by the judiciary."
Laurence Tribe in USA Today Tribe said "the pitchfork mentality" surrounding the House bill may make it "at least potentially vulnerable to attack under the bill of attainder clause."